We've compiled a list of 20 of the best pre-made shakes to help you decide which brand is best for your health and workout needs.


Best and Safe Pre-made Protein Shakes Comparison Chart

PRODUCT:

OverAll Rating

DETAILS

Iconic Chocolate Truffle Protein Drink

protein shakes: Iconic chocolate truffle protein drink

Fairlife Core Power Protein Milk Shake

protein shake: fairlife core power protein milkshake
protein shake: Carnation Chocolate Protein Drink, Breakfast Essentials
protein shake: Kellogg’s Special K Protein Bottles, Assorted
protein shake: Sportsman Protein Shake for Hunters, Six Flavors
protein shake
protein shake: Premier Chocolate Protein Shake
protein shake
protein shake: Boost Nutritional Strawberry, Chocolate or Vanilla Shake
protein shake
protein shakes: Atkins Mocha Latte Protein Drink
protein shakes: CalNaturale Organic Protein Variety
protein shakes: Optimum Nutrition Protein Drink, Watermelon
protein shakes
protein shakes: Labrada Ready to Drink Protein Shake, Various Flavors
protein shakes: Ensure High Protein Meal Replacement Shakes. Vanilla, Strawberry or Chocolate
protein shakes: CytoSport Chocolate or Vanilla Monster Shake
protein shakes: EAS AdvantEDGE Carb Control Protein Shake
protein shakes: Plant Fusion Chocolate Non-GMO Protein Shake
protein shakes: New Whey Watermelon Protein Supplement

Top 20 Best Safe, Pre-made Protein Shakes

Our list of the 20 best protein shakes includes a variety of brands, flavors and package styles (cans, bottles, tubes). The protein mixtures range from a few grams per container to as many as 50 grams.

Iconic Chocolate Truffle Protein Drink

protein shakes: Iconic chocolate truffle protein drink

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$$

Every bottle of Iconic Chocolate Truffle protein drink contains 20 grams of protein from grass-fed cows in New Zealand. A bottle of this protein shake has 130 calories, low-sugar and four grams of fiber. If you want to lose weight, stick to a keto-friendly diet or build muscle, this drink can help.

Online reviewers love the taste and the low-sugar formula. The protein content is well-tolerated by users who usually get headaches from protein drinks. The price is the only drawback mentioned by reviewers, but users say it is well worth the money.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Good taste
  • angle-double-right
    Does not induce headaches

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    More expensive than other brands

Fairlife Core Power Protein Milk Shake

protein shake: fairlife core power protein milkshake

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This gluten and soy-free shake have an impressive 26 grams of protein per bottle, and the Elite version of Core Power contains 42 grams. The 26-gram bottle is available in Strawberry Banana, Banana, Coffee, Vanilla, and Chocolate. The 42-gram shake comes in Vanilla and Chocolate.

The core Power lactose-free drink is made with ultra-fairlite milk and has nine essential amino acids and Vitamin D3. There are from ten to 26 grams of sugar in each bottle, depending on the size and flavor you choose. A regular bottle has 240 calories, and the light version has 150 calories.

Reviewers like the taste and lactose-free formula and one user called it a great supplement for a vegetarian diet.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Lactose-free formula
  • angle-double-right
    Vegan-friendly

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Average taste

Carnation Chocolate Protein Drink, Breakfast Essentials

protein shake: Carnation Chocolate Protein Drink, Breakfast Essentials

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

Carnation is well-known for its breakfast drinks and breakfast bars, and this chocolate-flavored Breakfast Essentials Drink has 15 grams of protein. Each bottle also contains calcium, Vitamin D and over a dozen other vitamins and minerals for better health. This drink is best used for nutritional reasons or as a meal replacement for busy people.

Reviewers love the taste and the thick consistency (although the drink is not as thick as a milkshake). One customer gives the drink to her underweight child to help him gain weight. Each bottle has 220 calories and 12 grams of sugar.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Good taste
  • angle-double-right
    Great Price

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Not for individuals with galactosemia

Kellogg’s Special Protein Bottles, Assorted

protein shake: Kellogg’s Special K Protein Bottles, Assorted

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

Kellogg’s Special K Cereal is a favorite breakfast for people trying to lose weight. Now the cereal company has protein shakes in five flavors – French Vanilla, Milk Chocolate, Strawberry, Rich Chocolate and Strawberry Banana. Every bottle has ten grams of protein, plus your recommended daily value of Vitamin A and Vitamin C.

This shake has a thin consistency and a light flavor. Most people use it as a breakfast substitute or as a meal replacement when they want to lose weight. Although it contains protein, it's not the best choice for a muscle builder or post-workout drink.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Ideal breakfast substitute
  • angle-double-right
    Ideal for losing weight

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Not for serious bodybuilders

Sportsman Protein Shake for Hunters, Six Flavors

protein shake: Sportsman Protein Shake for Hunters, Six Flavors

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This product is made specifically to give outdoorsmen (and women) energy and allow them to stay in the field longer. You can use it for general nutritional purposes, too. The Sportsman sugar-free shake contains 12 grams of protein from dairy milk, potassium, calcium, and electrolytes to renew your energy.

Reviewers like the creamy consistency and many people use this shake as a meal replacement when they're too busy to eat.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Ideal food substitute

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Limited availability

Strawberry Shake from American Body Building

protein shake: Strawberry Shake from American Body Building

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This shake has 50 grams of protein for serious bodybuilders and athletes. It has low sugar, minimal fat and a blend of whey and milk protein. The only negative comments from reviewers concerned it’s "chalky," sweet taste.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Low sugar
  • angle-double-right
    Low fat

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Chalky aftertaste

Premier Chocolate Protein Shake

protein shake: Premier Chocolate Protein Shake

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

Bodybuilders or anyone who wants to gain weight and muscle mass will benefit from a Premier Protein Shake. Each shake has 160 calories and 30 grams of protein. This shake is low in sugar and contains essential amino acids and two dozen vitamins and minerals.

This shake has received Chefs in America’s American Master of Taste Gold Medal. It has casein, whey protein, and milk protein to give you all the protein you need for workouts and healthier daily living.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Low sugar
  • angle-double-right
    Low fat

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Average taste

Orgain Kids Protein Organic Nutritional Shake

protein shake: Orgain Kids Protein Organic Nutritional Shake

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This nutritional, plant-based protein shake is the only one on our list specifically for kids. A pack of Orgain Chocolate Shakes for kids contains 12 8.25 ounce bottles. Each bottle has 200 calories, eight grams of protein, 21 vitamins and minerals and three grams of fiber.

Safe for even the most sensitive children, this drink is kosher, grass-fed and soy free. It contains no artificial flavors or colors.

There's even an organic veggie and fruit blend in each bottle, which includes kale, beet, spinach, raspberries, acai, and apple. It does contain milk, however, so it's not suitable for lactose-intolerant children.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    With organic vegetables

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Not for lactose intolerant children

Boost Nutritional Strawberry, Chocolate or Vanilla Shake

protein shake: Boost Nutritional Strawberry, Chocolate or Vanilla Shake

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This nutritional shake from Nestle is designed to give you more protein and vitamins to build and maintain muscles. Every bottle has 30% (15 grams) of the protein you need each day, along with 26 vitamins and minerals.

You can use Boost as a meal replacement, or drink it before or after a workout for muscle support. Each bottle has 240 calories.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Ideal meal replacement
  • angle-double-right
    Good pre or post-workout supplement

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Average taste

Orgain Chocolate Protein Shake

protein shake: Orgain Chocolate Protein Shake

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This chocolate fudge nutritional shake is one of several grass-fed protein shakes from Orgain, and it’s also available in Vanilla Bean flavor. It is kosher, non-GMO and gluten-free. Each bottle has 20 grams of protein from grass-fed cows, 140 calories and three grams of fiber.

Reviewers like the taste (it's not powdery), and the grass-fed formula. The all-natural ingredients make the shake taste great chilled or at room temperature.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Grass-fed formula
  • angle-double-right
    Gluten free

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Chalky aftertaste

Atkins Mocha Latte Protein Drink

protein shakes: Atkins Mocha Latte Protein Drink

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

You’ve probably heard of the protein-heavy Atkins Diet, and this Mocha Latte shake is one of several drinks offered by the Atkins nutritional supplement line.

One serving has 160 calories, ten to 15 grams of protein and one gram of sugar. Each bottle has 55.3 mg of caffeine, and some users say it has caused health problems for them. If you are sensitive to caffeine, this isn’t the best shake for you.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Low carb
  • angle-double-right
    Great taste

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    May disrupt sleep

CalNaturale Organic Protein Variety

protein shakes: CalNaturale Organic Protein Variety

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

CalNaturale Organic is a plant-based, gluten-free protein shake with five grams of fiber and 11 grams of protein. You can drink it pre or post-workout, or use it as a meal replacement.

These protein shakes are available in Spiced Chai, Cappuccino, French Vanilla Chocolate, and Banana Crème. This non-dairy shake is made with soy milk and contains very little sugar.

CalNaturale products have little to no caffeine so that these shakes won't give you the jitters.

Online reviewers write that it's a good fill-in for skipped meals, but a little "thin." Users who develop stomach problems after drinking shakes with sugar, additives or preservatives can drink CalNaturale without unpleasant side effects.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Organic
  • angle-double-right
    Gluten free

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Not for stevia sensitive people

Optimum Nutrition Protein Drink, Watermelon

protein shakes: Optimum Nutrition Protein Drink, Watermelon

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

This drink is a little different from our other choices. It has one gram of protein and is more of a drink than a frothy shake, but it has the nutritional and energy-boosting power of the milkshake protein products.

You can drink a bottle of Optimum Energy and Protein Drink after a workout for muscle recovery. Reviewers give this product high marks, except for the artificial colors.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    High amino acid
  • angle-double-right
    Drink any-time formula 

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Artificial coloring

Organic Valley Vanilla Bean Protein Shake, Breakfast Balance

protein shakes: Organic Valley Vanilla Bean Protein Shake, Breakfast Balance

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$$

The latest Breakfast Balance protein shake is creamier and has less sugar than previous versions. It contains 170 calories, 16 grams of protein and no artificial sweeteners, gluten or soy. This shake is non-GMO and certified organic, and can be served cold or kept on the shelf.

Users like the taste and one customer commented that it is excellent for lactose-intolerant people and anyone with Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS).

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    No GMO and antibiotics
  • angle-double-right
    Good for lactose intolerant

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Expensive than other brands

Labrada Ready to Drink Protein Shake, Various Flavors

protein shakes: Labrada Ready to Drink Protein Shake, Various Flavors

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$$

The Labrada Lean Body Ready to Drink protein shake has an award-winning taste and 40 grams of protein to help you build or repair muscles. It has no sugar and is lactose and gluten-free, so it's safe for anyone to drink. If you want to lose weight, this drink helps you burn fat while it tones muscles.

Available in eight flavors, including cookies and cream, vanilla, chocolate and bananas, and cream.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    No sugar
  • angle-double-right
    Lactose and gluten-free

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Expensive than other brands

Ensure High Protein Meal Replacement Shakes. Vanilla, Strawberry or Chocolate

protein shakes: Ensure High Protein Meal Replacement Shakes. Vanilla, Strawberry or Chocolate

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

Ensure is a well-known brand name that is usually associated with energy drinks for older adults. The High Protein drink helps you build muscle and stay active longer, regardless of your age. It has 16 grams of protein, 160 calories, and 23 vitamins and minerals.

Once you open a bottle of Ensure, you should refrigerate it within four hours, and discard it within 48 hours.

Pros

  • High-quality protein
  • Suitable for lactose intolerance
  • Gluten free

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Poor packaging

CytoSport Chocolate or Vanilla Monster Shake

protein shakes: CytoSport Chocolate or Vanilla Monster Shake

Quality

Price

Our Rating

$

If you need lots of protein for sports, bodybuilding this drink comes in a 17 ounce can and gives you all you need in one serving. The CytoSport monster shake contains 48 grams of protein and 260 calories.

This shake is not as popular as some of the other drinks on our list, but reviews indicate customers like it for its taste and high protein content. One reviewer used it to gain weight after an illness.

Pros

  • angle-double-right
    Vegan-friendly
  • angle-double-right
    No synthetic dyes or artificial sweeteners

Cons

  • angle-double-right
    Average taste

EAS AdvantEDGE Carb Control Protein Shake

protein shakes: EAS AdvantEDGE Carb Control Protein Shake

Quality

Price

Our Rating